The question of whether India is first a nation or a union of states is a non sequitur

Highlight>

The question of whether India is first a nation or a union of states is a non sequitur

By Gilles Verniers

The Economic Times

February 10, 2022

Rahul Gandhi’s recent intervention in the Lok Sabha struck a nerve when he reminded the majority in Parliament that India is first and foremost a union of states, and that the rights of states ought to be respected and protected. One could nitpick about his other claim that India, therefore, is less of a nation than a union of states. But it remains true that India has recently seen a process of political centralisation that it hasn’t experienced since the Emergency in the late 1970s under Indira.

Publisher Page>

STATEMENT

January 17th, 2024

On 10th January 2024, CPR received a notice from the Ministry of Home Affairs cancelling its FCRA status. The basis of this decision is incomprehensible and disproportionate, and some of the reasons given challenge the very basis of the functioning of a research institution. This includes the publication on our website of policy reports emanating from our research being equated with current affairs programming.

During the tenure of our suspension, we sought and obtained interim redress from the honourable Delhi High Court and will continue to seek recourse in all avenues possible.

This cancellation comes after a decision to suspend the FCRA status in February 2023. These actions followed an Income Tax “survey” that took place in September 2022. The actions have had a debilitating impact on the institution’s ability to function by choking all sources of funding. This has undermined the institution’s ability to pursue its well established objective of producing high quality, globally recognised research on policy matters, which it has been recognised for over its 50 years’ existence. During this time the institution has been home to some of the country’s most distinguished academics, diplomats and policymakers.

CPR firmly reiterates that it is in complete compliance with the law, and has been cooperating fully and exhaustively at every step of the process. We remain steadfast in our belief that this matter will be resolved in line with constitutional values and guarantees.

From the President, CPR

Opinion and commentary

The question of whether India is first a nation or a union of states is a non sequitur

By Gilles Verniers