The Future of India-China Relations

Listen to the 44th episode of ThoughtSpace (above) featuring Shyam Saran, Former Foreign Secretary and Senior Fellow, CPR and Yamini Aiyar, President & Chief Executive of CPR.

In the last few weeks, a crisis has been brewing on our borders between India and China over the Line of Actual Control (LAC). Late last week, in an unprecedented move, top Generals from both countries met to seek a resolution to the crisis. The discussions have opened up the prospects of a second phase of dialogues. Against the backdrop of these dialogues, we explore the dynamics of India-China relations, the nature of this particular border dispute and the immediate and long-term implications this may have on India-China ties.

Saran, who is an expert on China, sheds light on the history of border disputes with China despite the LAC, the growing asymmetry of power between the two countries and calls for constraining Chinese aggression by cultivating strong ties with countries like the US. He also highlights that it is important to continue engaging on issues that may be mutually beneficial while at the same time confronting China where Indian interests are being threatened.

The future of the New Education Policy

AN ANALYSIS
EDUCATION

The Public Accountability and Governance in Education (PAGE) project at CPR has written a series of policy briefs and analytical articles in the run-up to the New Education Policy (NEP), 2015, to be announced next month.

The NEP will be revised after more than a decade, and will be critical in defining access to and unversalisation of quality education, going forward.For a more detailed understanding of the processes and issues, read below:

Policy brief exploring how the NEP will impact school education: School Education in New Education Policy.
Policy brief analysing the importance of the no-detention policy and continuous and comprehensive evaluation, which is part of the RTE: No-Detention Policy and Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation.
Opinion pieces by Kiran Bhatty:
On the importance of consulting experts in the process of framing the Policy: Don’t Make Experts the Enemy in Framing a New Education Policy.
On a complete lack of a systematic assessment of the problems in the school sector to accurately inform the NEP: You Can’t Get the New Education Policy Right by Asking the Wrong Questions.

The Future We Need: Natural Resources as a Shared Inheritance

FULL AUDIO OF TALK
RIGHTS ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE

Watch the full video (above) of the talk by Rahul Basu, where he speaks about the work of the Goa Foundation, an environmental NGO, in raising awareness about mining being Goa’s largest environmental issue for over twenty five years

In this talk, he discusses the Goa Foundation’s ‘fair mining’ proposal, which uses the ‘public trust’ doctrine and the ‘intergenerational equity’ principle to propose an ethical, fair and just resolution to the mining issue. Basu explains how the proposal also contributes to reducing poverty, slowing the growing inequality, reducing corruption and crony capitalism, improving governance and even creating a palatable ‘Universal Basic Income’.

Rahul Basu is presently a member of a number of initiatives, including the Goa Foundation, the Goenchi Mati Movement, and The Future We Need. He is on the executive committee of Mines, Minerals and People and the interim executive committee of the India Network for Basic Income.

The BRICS Summit

21 October 2016
The BRICS Summit
CURATED ANALYSIS BY CPR FACULTY

 

Both in the run-up to, and post the BRICS summit, faculty at CPR have commented on it analysing the potential (with a special focus on India-China relations) and the outcomes. Find below a curated analysis.

  • In the run-up to the BRICS summit, Srinath Raghavan historically analyses the India-China relationship over seven decades in the Hindustan Timesstating that both countries need to show ‘mutual restraint’ to arrest ongoing deterioration in ties, spurred by wider issues that go beyond bilateral disputes.
  • Shaym Saran too historically contextualises the India-China relationship in the Business Standard, commenting on how its strategic and global dimension has weakened over the last decade, arguing that India must build her internal ‘economic and security capabilities’, and begin to close the power gap with China.
  • Commenting on the BRICS summit, Brahma Chellaney writes on how the Goa summit was a reminder that the BRICS countries were ‘yet to devise a common action plan to go forward’, in order to have any collective international influence.
  • G Parthasarathy also analyses the BRICS summit, commenting on India’s achievement of giving new momentum to relations with Russia, while questioning India’s strategy to address Chinese intentions of containing her.

The Broken Ladder: The Paradox and the Potential of India’s One Billion

FULL VIDEO OF TALK
ECONOMY

Watch the full video (above) of the talk by Anirudh Krishna, based on his book ‘The Broken Ladder’, which delves into the lives of ordinary individuals to take a ground-up view towards answering questions about the potential of civic participation in the growth of India’s economy.

Through decades-long investigations conducted on the ground, living in villages and investigating slum communities, Krishna reveals the eye-opening details of missed opportunities and the immense, but untapped, talent that can and should be honed, with immense consequences for both growth and equity. From presenting possible solutions to the problems of neediness and inequity, to mulling over ways of fixing inequalities of opportunity, his book provides a comprehensive account of India’s development strategies.

Anirudh Krishna is the Edgar T. Thompson Professor of Public Policy and professor of political science at Duke University, USA. His research investigates how poor communities and individuals in developing countries cope with the structural and personal constraints that result in poverty and powerlessness.

The centralisation vs decentralisation tug of war and the emerging narrative of fiscal federalism for social policy in India

Image Source: The Hindu
6 May 2019
The centralisation vs decentralisation tug of war and the emerging narrative of fiscal federalism for social policy in India
JOURNAL ARTICLE BY YAMINI AIYAR AND AVANI KAPUR

 

This paper examines the relationship between fiscal federalism and social policy in India through an analysis of the effects of a recent effort to increase fiscal decentralisation to state governments on the nature of social policy investment at the sub-national level. Through its analysis, this paper highlights the persistence of a strong centralisation bias in India’s fiscal architecture for social policy. We trace this centralisation bias to the political and administrative dynamics of the federal bargain. The peculiar dynamics of this bargain have created a context where the core goal of centralisation – to ensure equity – is undermined while the expectation of decentralisation – greater accountability through alignment of expenditure with local needs and preferences, fails to take root. India is thus likely to continue to witness significant regional variation in social policy outcomes, despite a centralised financing architecture.

The full journal article can be accessed here.

The centralisation vs. decentralisation tug of war and the emerging narrative of fiscal federalism for social policy in India

18 October 2018
The centralisation vs. decentralisation tug of war and the emerging narrative of fiscal federalism for social policy in India
NEW JOURNAL ARTICLE CO-AUTHORED BY YAMINI AIYAR AND AVANI KAPUR

 

This paper examines the relationship between fiscal federalism and social policy in India through an analysis of the effects of a recent effort to increase fiscal decentralisation to state governments on the nature of social policy investment at the sub-national level. Through its analysis, this paper highlights the persistence of a strong centralisation bias in India’s fiscal architecture for social policy. The paper traces this centralisation bias to the political and administrative dynamics of the federal bargain. The peculiar dynamics of this bargain have created a context where the core goal of centralisation – to ensure equity – is undermined while the expectation of decentralisation – greater accountability through alignment of expenditure with local needs and preferences, fails to take root. India is thus likely to continue to witness significant regional variation in social policy outcomes, despite a centralised financing architecture

Link to the journal article can be accessed here.

The Cleaning Brigade: Connects and Disconnects

FULL VIDEO OF CORP SEMINAR
SANITATION URBAN SERVICES

Watch the full video (above) of the CORP Seminar by Dr Sanghmitra Acharya addressing the factors characterising sanitation work and how the instricially discriminatory nature of this work impacts the lives of the workers.

With a focus on the experiences of Dalits engaged in scavenging and cleaning, Dr Acharya argues that, while a majority of the literature around the issue explores social discrimination in general, it does not adequately reflect on the experience of social discrimination and humiliation experienced by these workers; and consequences of such experiences.

Dr Acharya is Director, Indian Institute of Dalit Studies, New Delhi.

The question and answer session that followed can be accessed here.

This is the 13th in the series of the Community of Research and Practice (CORP) seminars planned by the Scaling City Institutions for India: Sanitation (SCI-FI: Sanitation) initiative. More information can be found at the event page.

The Coronavirus Pandemic: A Global Perspective

17 April 2020
The Coronavirus Pandemic: A Global Perspective
PODCAST FEATURING DR CHRISTIANA IYASERE, DR SAUMYA DAS, DR NIM PATHY, DR JISHNU DAS AND YAMINI AIYAR

 

Listen to episode 37 of ThoughtSpace (above) featuring Dr Christiana Iyasere, Dr Saumya Das, Dr Nim Pathy, Dr Jishnu Das and Yamini Aiyar.

While India goes into lockdown 2.0 and determines the best strategies to stop the spread of COVID-19, countries across the world have adopted myriad approaches to tackle the outbreak. In this episode, we step away from India to look at what is happening across the world, especially in the United States of America. We also delve deeper into understanding epidemiological models – what is required to build sound models and to what extent can they accurately predict the spread of disease. While the episode does not focus on India, we do probe lessons India can learn from what is happening in other parts of the world.

In the fifth episode on the Centre for Policy Research’s series on the coronavirus pandemic, co-hosts Yamini Aiyar, President & Chief Executive of CPR, and Dr Jishnu Das, Senior Fellow at CPR and Professor at Georgetown University dive into the medical, testing, and epidemiological aspects of COVID-19. They speak with Dr Christiana Iyasere and Dr Saumya Das, doctors at the Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston, and Dr Nim Pathy, an epidemiologist at Imperial College, London.

Iyasere, Das and Pathy talk to us about why the disease manifests differently in different people, speculation over aerosol versus droplet transmission, different testing mechanisms, variation in epidemiological model and whether or not comparisons between countries is justified.

This is the fifth in a series of episodes by the Centre for Policy Research on the unfolding coronavirus pandemic in India. You can follow the Centre’s work on Covid-19 on Twitter or visit www.cprindia.org. You can listen to all the episodes in the Coronavirus Conversation series here.

The Coronavirus Pandemic: Dealing with the Economic Crisis

9 April 2020
The Coronavirus Pandemic: Dealing with the Economic Crisis
PODCAST FEATURING DR RATHIN ROY AND YAMINI AIYAR

 

Listen to the 35th episode of ThoughtSpace (above) featuring Dr Rathin Roy and Yamini Aiyar.

The coronavirus pandemic and subsequent 21-day national lockdown have brought the Indian economy to a standstill. This comes at a time when India’s economy and public finances were already under considerable strain. It is with this backdrop that India must think about how it can deal with the current crisis and rebuild its economy once the immediacy of the public health crisis dissipates. How should the government generate finances and design a fiscal package to stimulate the economy? What must the government do to protect all Indians, especially the poor and vulnerable, and ensure they have income and food security?

In the third episode on the Centre for Policy Research’s series on the coronavirus pandemic, Yamini Aiyar, President & Chief Executive of CPR, speaks with Dr Rathin Roy, Director of the National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP). Roy recommends thinking of the economy as a wartime economy where all resources are devoted to dealing with the pandemic medically, socially, and at the community level. He highlights that India could see a massive erosion in national wealth and national income if the proportion of the crisis reaches even a fraction of what it is in countries like the USA and China.

Roy calls for a rethinking of the social contract; increased accountability from the government to ensure that money is spent for the purposes it has been allocated for; and adequate financing to states so that they can take measures to tackle the crisis.

This is the third in a series of episodes on the unfolding coronavirus pandemic in India. The first episode looked at how prepared India’s health systems are to deal with the pandemic and the second looked at the crisis of migrant workers. You can find a link to the episode in our show notes (https://soundcloud.com/cpr_india/episode33 and https://soundcloud.com/cpr_india/episode34). Stay tuned for updates on future episodes. For more information on our work on COVID-19, follow us on Twitter @CPR_India or visit our website at www.cprindia.org.